Self-Portrait
The content
of this painting violates our surmise of what such a title usually intends.
The boy who grew up in pre-war Vilna with an intact family is not the
same as the one who survived the catastrophe remembering a murdered father
and ruined community. The Holocaust has shattered the notion of a unified
self. Indeed, the center of the picture is dominated not by the face of
the living boy, but by the replica of the dead one, taken from the most
famous photograph to emerge from the disaster. It reveals a frightened
child, hands raised, being led from what might have been his hiding place
in the Warsaw ghetto. His is a "counter-portrait," though the
two likenesses are really inseparable, since the fate of the boy who was
Bak is intimately linked to the to the doom of the victim whose image
is imprinted on a crude assemblage of panels and canvas. On the left are
some wooden cutouts of the posture that will be reproduced, the bullet-holes
in the palms changing on the portrait into the stigmata of a crucified
Christ. One of the muted themes of the entire series is the question of
Christian responsibility for the destruction of European Jewry. The boy
has only to straighten his arms to assume a cruciform position. At his
elbow joint are two pieces of wood in the form of a tilted cross, though
their X-shape also suggests the mystery of iniquity and
as a Roman numeral 10 the defilement of the
ten commandments.
Among
other challenges, these paintings invite us to read their signs as complex
visual images of strands of atrocity that will be rewoven into a tapestry
of art. The rhythms of creation must somehow absorb the jagged heritage
of loss. Like the ghost of Hamlet's father, the figure of the dead with
raised arms imposes a blessing-curse on the seated child: "Remember
me!" Whatever he achieves in the future, the living boy will be haunted
by the memory of all the lost childhoods, including his own. The implement
in his hand, presumably the shaft of a paintbrush, is a harbinger of his
vocation, though Freudian commentators might also want to see in this
detail a bond between creative and sexual energy....
The boy
himself gazes at us like a post-Holocaust Mona Lisa, though his somber
mouth betrays no hint of a smile. Instead both eyes and lips bid us to
consider the violent past that has etched itself onto his inner vision.
As this bitter seed sprouts and blooms, what role will it play in the
later creation of the Landscapes of Jewish Experience?
The viewer
is also invited to reflect on a sturdy pair of empty shoes, all that remains
of a vast population of Jews whose bodies have been turned to ash. Who
will wear them now, and how will he or she carry on the tradition of Jewish
memory once transmitted by their former occupants? This question is deepened
by the small stones in the foreground, holding down blank sheets of paper,
reminding us of how the Holocaust has disrupted familiar Jewish customs
for remembering the dead. Are these empty pages part of a Torah scroll
at the boy's feet, and with what text will they be re-inscribed? Belching
smokestacks in the distance. as well as hints of a community in flames,
summon us to a vista of crimes whose impact will be portrayed in the subsequent
paintings of the series.
back
|